Takaful vs Conventional Car Insurance

What is conventional car insurance?

Insurance is a contractual agreement designed to protect one party from financial losses. In this arrangement, the insured individual agrees to pay a premium and file a claim within a specified timeframe in return for this protection.

While the specifics of the contract vary based on the type of coverage, they all share common essential elements. These typically include clauses outlining the covered and excluded losses.

What is Takaful?

Takaful operates much like conventional insurance, yet it operates in accordance with Islamic principles. As such, Takaful is not exclusive to Muslims; individuals from any faith can also enjoy its benefits.

What are the differences?

Conventional insurance Takaful
How does it work?
A contract between two parties to get protection A promise between members of a community to help each other in times of need
No Yes
Where are the funds invested in?
Any legal investment Any shariah-compliant investment
Where do the profits go?
Shareholders Participants and operators of the Takaful fund
Extra charges
Commission fee of 2% Wakalah charge depending on the product
Insurer Among the participants

What are the similarities?

Conventional insurance Takaful
What is it?
A way to safeguard ourselves against the unexpected misfortune
Types of insurance offered
Car, medical, life, home, travel etc.
Who can buy it?
Tax relief claim

Importance of insurance and Takaful

They are a safety net against financial losses, and we all hope we never have to use them. But when life throws us a curveball, it’s good to know that our policy will help cover the costs. For example, if a person becomes sick or injured and cannot work, medical insurance or Takaful will help pay for their medical expenses. Similarly, if a business suffers damage to its property, it can help cover the lost income. The bottom line is: insurance and Takaful are an essential part of financial planning.

The reason why Muslims are advised to purchase Takaful

Conventional insurance is often not compatible with Sharia law due to its inclusion of these three elements: gharar, riba, and maisir.

    • Gharar:

The element of uncertainty in the contract. The contract should be clear, and there should be no ambiguity.

    • Riba:

The element of interest. In insurance, the insured pays a premium, which the insurer uses to cover claims and make a profit. The insurer makes a guaranteed profit, regardless of whether there are claims.

    • Maisir:

The element of gambling. The insured is gambling that they will have an accident or their property will be damaged, while the insurer is gambling that they will not have an accident or their property will not be damaged.

It is a much more suitable option for Muslims who wish to obtain insurance complying with their religious beliefs.

Advantages and disadvantages of insurance and Takaful

If you’ve ever found yourself asking the question, “Should I get conventional insurance or Takaful?” then you’re not alone. When it comes to insurance, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Conventional insurance and Takaful both have their pros and cons, which comes down to what an individual prefers.

Here are the advantages and disadvantages of conventional insurance:

Advantages Disadvantages
Offered by more insurers Profits go to shareholders
Fixed commission fee (2%) Includes non shariah-compliant elements
Investment-linked plan is available Premium rate depends on risk assessment

Here are the advantages and disadvantages of Takaful:

Advantages Disadvantages
Shariah compliant Offered by limited insurers
Profits go to participants and operators* Wakalah charge depends on the price of the product
Fixed premium rate**
Umrah and Hajj Takaful plan is available

*Amount for operators can’t be higher than participants
**Unless you’re with severe health issues

Can non-Muslims purchase Takaful?

When it comes to Takaful, everyone is on an equal footing. Whether you’re Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, or atheist, you can purchase a policy and enjoy the same benefits. Takaful is not a religious product but a product designed to protect everyone in an unexpected event, regardless of their beliefs. And that’s something we can all feel good about.

Where to purchase insurance and Takaful

Conventional insurance Takaful
  1. AIA
  2. AIG
  3. Allianz
  4. AmMetLife / AmAssurance
  5. AXA
  6. Berjaya Sompo
  7. Gibraltar BSN
  8. Chubb
  9. Danajamin
  10. Etiqa
  11. Great Eastern
  12. Hong Leong
  13. Kurnia
  14. Liberty Insurance
  15. Lonpac
  16. Manulife
  17. MCIS
  18. MPI Generali
  19. MSIG
  20. Pacific & Orient
  21. Pacific Insurance
  22. Progressive Insurance
  23. Prudential
  24. QBE
  25. RHB Insurance
  26. Sun Life Malaysia
  27. Tokio Marine
  28. Tune Protect
  29. Zurich
  1. AIA
  2. AmMetLife
  3. Etiqa
  4. FWD
  5. Great Eastern
  6. MSIG
  7. Prudential BSN
  8. Sun Life Malaysia
  9. Syarikat Takaful Malaysia
  10. Takaful Ikhlas
  11. Zurich

For fast and hassle-free service, you can purchase insurance and Takaful through PolicyStreet!

How to purchase insurance and Takaful

  1. Decide on what type of coverage you need.
  2. Decide whether you want conventional insurance or Takaful.
  3. Do some research on insurers.
  4. Choose three preferred insurers.
  5. Ask for quotations.
  6. Compare the coverage and price.
  7. Provide your details and relevant documents.
  8. Make payment.


If you’re looking for a Shariah-compliant and inclusive insurance solution with a fixed premium rate, Takaful is the way to go. However, if you prefer a more comprehensive selection of insurers and a fixed commission fee, conventional insurance may be a better option for you. Whichever route you decide to take, make sure to do your research and find the best insurance policy for your needs. Ultimately, it all depends on what you’re looking for.

Still confused? You can get your insurance with PolicyStreet and leave all the headaches with us. Get the quotation for your personalised insurance plan within 5 minutes with the best price!

PolicyStreet is licensed by Labuan Financial Services Authority, Bank Negara Malaysia and Australian Securities & Investments Commission.

Copyright © 2023 Polisea Group of Companies. All Rights Reserved.